Silent Hill
2006
Starring: Radha Mitchell, Sean Bean, Deborah Kara Unger, Laurie Holden, Kim Coates
Directed By: Christophe Gans
I heard a lot of good things about this movie and decided to give it a chance. First off, let me say that I'm of above average intelligence and consider myself very knowledgable when it comes to films and filmmaking. Second, let me say that I've never once played any Silent Hill video game, which this movie was based on.
Silent Hill is very confusing if you haven't played the games, so I did my own research (which I'll get to later) after watching this movie. I'll do my best to sum up what it's about without giving away any spoilers.
When Sharon starts having bad dreams about a place called Silent Hill, her parents start to freak. Her mother, Rose (Radha Mitchell), decides (against her husband's better wishes) to take their adopted daughter to Silent Hill to try and figure out why her daughter is creeping them the Hell out. On the way to Silent Hill West Virginia, the two are pulled over by a female motorcycle cop who looks like she was trying desperately to be in Terminator 2. Anyway, they crash and when Rose comes to, her daughter is missing, thus she begins the descent into Silent Hill to find her with the cop in tow. The Silent Hill they see is completely atmospheric and rains grey ash constantly.
Now, after realizing that his wife took his daughter on a road trip to Hell, Christopher (Sean Bean) sets off after them. Now, once he gets there a detective goes with him to Silent Hill to look for his family. However, the Silent Hill that he goes to is abandoned, but looks fairly normal. After searching and coming up with nothing, he's escorted out of the town and told not to come back. Meanwhile, Rose and her cop buddy search all of Silent Hill to find Sharon and find out what the fuck is going on.
To be honest, after watching the movie, I had no clue what the fuck was going on or happened and I felt that the characters didn't either. So, I did my own research. Apparently, there are three different dimensions that they are all in once they get to Silent Hill. Ok, not that hard to explain, right? So... WHY THE FUCK COULDN'T THE FILMMAKERS HAVE TAKEN TEN SECONDS TO EXPLAIN THIS? Instead, they leave you with a shitty ending to a movie that just falls flat. Oh, did I mention that the movie is just over two hours long? It is. By the time they start explaining stuff, you just want to see people die. I had to research this and find out what the fuck is going on in the games to understand what I had just watched. However, as good a job as they did making Silent Hill creepy, they could have done just as good a job explaining stuff, but it seems they made this film just for the kids who geek out to the Silent Hill games. It's sad really, because this film had the potential to be a good horror movie. It started out ok, but the more you get into it, the more confusing it gets, and the less the filmmakers explain.
As far as the acting goes, it's really good. However I doubt that anyone really understood the script or what was happening. The script however is flat. Completely devoid of any personality or emotion and it's very monotone. It's like watching Larry King for two fucking hours. The dialogue is good and isn't cheesy, but that's because they got decent actors to be in it. Sean Bean really stands out as the father here, and the rest of the cast is good, but you can tell the script didn't make sense to them. It's like they all got hired to act out a physics manual.
The script: horrible. In fact, it's so convoluted and bland that I was begging for someone to die or actually do something stupid that would cause death. If they had trimmed down about fifteen minutes and actually had the damn thing make sense and took the time to explain what's happening instead of watching the mother walk all over a grey town covered in ashes, it might have been worth watching.
The editing and special fx are about all I can say nice things about besides the acting. They are ok at best and nice to watch, but the script is so terrible that you wished you were watching something else. In Silent Hill, the script hurts the good points so bad that it's almost enough to make you want to decapitate yourself. I can't believe Roger Avary wrote this garbage. Now I know why he just got a "story by" credit on Pulp Fiction.
The directing was actually shitty. Coming from the guy who directed The Brotherhood of the Wolf, I would expect more. In fact, I would expect more from a third grader who has actually played the Silent Hill games. I guess we'll see him directing the next direct-to-DVD Look Who's Talking or Stewart Little movie.
When it's all said and done, Silent Hill is like going to the fridge and seeing an ice-cold refreshing 2-liter of Pepsi, pouring yourself a tall glass, and then finding out that your Pepsi is flatter than fucking roadkill.
Rating: 



